A middle school student just tried to tell me “guns and roses” was “country music”
-
@futurebird never stopped being true xD
@moira @futurebird
As a child of the west who had met no New Yorkers, that particular New Yorker cover amused me when I first saw it.When I was older and started to meet New Yorkers, my opinion changed.
I've always wanted to do one in reverse, where the "east" basically starts at Denver and Boston, New York, Philly, DC, etc. are all essentially in Europe.
-
@moira @futurebird
As a child of the west who had met no New Yorkers, that particular New Yorker cover amused me when I first saw it.When I was older and started to meet New Yorkers, my opinion changed.
I've always wanted to do one in reverse, where the "east" basically starts at Denver and Boston, New York, Philly, DC, etc. are all essentially in Europe.
Just say “new york is in new England” this makes people from here irrationally angry and although I’ve lived here most of my life as someone from the midwest I don’t think I’ll ever understand why.
(it is very funny though… be subtle about it eg “New York, Hartford and other new england cities”)
-
F myrmepropagandist shared this topic
-
A middle school student just tried to tell me “guns and roses” was “country music”
?????
@futurebird They did cover Dylan's "Knockin' on Heaven's Door", which is *kinda* country-ish.
(Funny story from a Grateful Dead chat on AOL back in the early 90's: Leaving a concert during the encore (Knockin'), someone heard some kids behind him remark, "oh, they're playing a Guns & Roses song!")
-
@futurebird They did cover Dylan's "Knockin' on Heaven's Door", which is *kinda* country-ish.
(Funny story from a Grateful Dead chat on AOL back in the early 90's: Leaving a concert during the encore (Knockin'), someone heard some kids behind him remark, "oh, they're playing a Guns & Roses song!")
@ObbieZ omg
-
Just say “new york is in new England” this makes people from here irrationally angry and although I’ve lived here most of my life as someone from the midwest I don’t think I’ll ever understand why.
(it is very funny though… be subtle about it eg “New York, Hartford and other new england cities”)
@futurebird @geoffduncan @moira I used to hear that City Island (Bronx) was New England by New Yorkers even back in the day when the landfill near the bridge was active and very aromatic. It was probably due to the small town feel and the large number of small boats.
-
@futurebird @geoffduncan @moira I used to hear that City Island (Bronx) was New England by New Yorkers even back in the day when the landfill near the bridge was active and very aromatic. It was probably due to the small town feel and the large number of small boats.
@Bongolian @geoffduncan @moira
I can almost see it. And now I’m hungry for the clam bake they have up there at the creepy Italian restaurant.
-
Just say “new york is in new England” this makes people from here irrationally angry and although I’ve lived here most of my life as someone from the midwest I don’t think I’ll ever understand why.
(it is very funny though… be subtle about it eg “New York, Hartford and other new england cities”)
@futurebird @moira
I'm going to put that one in my bag of things to say to New Yorkers.
One of my favorites is NYC people learning I'm from Nevada. "Oh, what was it like to grow up in Vegas?" "Vegas is as close to where I grew up as you are to, say, Rochester."
-
Just say “new york is in new England” this makes people from here irrationally angry and although I’ve lived here most of my life as someone from the midwest I don’t think I’ll ever understand why.
(it is very funny though… be subtle about it eg “New York, Hartford and other new england cities”)
@futurebird @geoffduncan As someone who lived in Massachusetts for some years, let me assure you New Englanders would be just as angry.
Northeastern upstate New York, _maybe_. MAYBE. If it's in the very northeast. Ithaca, because of Cornell, MAYBE. But it's a... not oblast, what's the word. ENCLAVE. It's an enclave. AT BEST.
And yes, it is funny. xD
-
@futurebird @moira
I'm going to put that one in my bag of things to say to New Yorkers.One of my favorites is NYC people learning I'm from Nevada. "Oh, what was it like to grow up in Vegas?" "Vegas is as close to where I grew up as you are to, say, Rochester."
@geoffduncan @futurebird From a chat with with some born and bred New Yorkers as in NYC, some years ago:
Them: "How do _you_ pronounce Schenectady?"
Me: "I don't, I usually say Poughkeepsie or Leonardsville and nobody knows the difference."
Them: "EXACTLY. Because all those fucking upstate towns are EXACTLY THE SAME."
-
@futurebird @geoffduncan As someone who lived in Massachusetts for some years, let me assure you New Englanders would be just as angry.
Northeastern upstate New York, _maybe_. MAYBE. If it's in the very northeast. Ithaca, because of Cornell, MAYBE. But it's a... not oblast, what's the word. ENCLAVE. It's an enclave. AT BEST.
And yes, it is funny. xD
@moira @futurebird @geoffduncan Lake George, maybe?
-
@moira @futurebird @geoffduncan Lake George, maybe?
@mattmcirvin @futurebird @geoffduncan Oh yeah, basically, anything in or around the Adirondacks mostly counted. At least, to anyone who didn't draw a hard line at the NYS border.
(And certainly did _not_ count to the extremists who excised Hartford and Boston, tho' I can sympathise with anyone who wants to excise Connecticut in general. xD )
-
A middle school student just tried to tell me “guns and roses” was “country music”
?????
@futurebird
When I was in elementary school, I had a pen pal who wrote that he liked guns and roses. I didn't know about the band at the time, so I just thought... those are two weirdly different interests, but ok, let's talk about roses I guess. -
@mattmcirvin @futurebird @geoffduncan Oh yeah, basically, anything in or around the Adirondacks mostly counted. At least, to anyone who didn't draw a hard line at the NYS border.
(And certainly did _not_ count to the extremists who excised Hartford and Boston, tho' I can sympathise with anyone who wants to excise Connecticut in general. xD )
@moira @futurebird @geoffduncan Refusing to admit Boston as part of New England does seem pretty extreme!
-
@geoffduncan @futurebird From a chat with with some born and bred New Yorkers as in NYC, some years ago:
Them: "How do _you_ pronounce Schenectady?"
Me: "I don't, I usually say Poughkeepsie or Leonardsville and nobody knows the difference."
Them: "EXACTLY. Because all those fucking upstate towns are EXACTLY THE SAME."
Excuse me what.
If I went for a nice weekend in Saratoga but ended up in Albany I would not be happy.
But the real wild ones will call Yonkers “upstate” — I know people in the Bronx who do this.
-
Excuse me what.
If I went for a nice weekend in Saratoga but ended up in Albany I would not be happy.
But the real wild ones will call Yonkers “upstate” — I know people in the Bronx who do this.
@futurebird @moira @geoffduncan
If it's in New York state, on the US mainland, and the MTA (including metro north) can't get me there, it's upstate
-
@futurebird @moira @geoffduncan
If it's in New York state, on the US mainland, and the MTA (including metro north) can't get me there, it's upstate
This is exactly why they keep posting that damn cartoon.
-
@moira @futurebird @geoffduncan Refusing to admit Boston as part of New England does seem pretty extreme!
@mattmcirvin @moira @geoffduncan
I guess this is the New England means it’s a fishing village school of thinking?
-
Just say “new york is in new England” this makes people from here irrationally angry and although I’ve lived here most of my life as someone from the midwest I don’t think I’ll ever understand why.
(it is very funny though… be subtle about it eg “New York, Hartford and other new england cities”)
@futurebird @geoffduncan @moira reminds me of when folks call Denver a “Midwestern city.”
-
@futurebird @geoffduncan @moira reminds me of when folks call Denver a “Midwestern city.”
No no no no no no. Yes it is in the middle. Technically. That is where THAT ends.
-
Just say “new york is in new England” this makes people from here irrationally angry and although I’ve lived here most of my life as someone from the midwest I don’t think I’ll ever understand why.
(it is very funny though… be subtle about it eg “New York, Hartford and other new england cities”)
@futurebird @geoffduncan @moira
Pfft. New York City is more New Jersey than it is New England.
