A forum for discussing and organizing recreational softball and baseball games and leagues in the greater Halifax area.
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 takes home an absurd 9 wins at The Game Awards, more than Baldur's Gate 3 in 2023
-
I won't say E33 didn't deserve to win an award, it definitely did. But I will absolutely say with certainty it did not deserve to be nominated in so many categories and proceed to win basically every category. Having an award show give awards to only one nominee feels bad for everyone except the show runners, that one nominee, and their fans. Lots of games deserved to be there that simply weren't, and lots of nominees deserved to win but didn't simply because E33 won this year's popularity contest. For example, Best Performance should not have been allowed to have 50% of the nominees be from the same game (E33, in this case).I get where you're coming from, but awards shows shouldn't be participation trophies. The panels should give the awards for each category to the games they think were the best in that category. And games aren't made by a single person. If they decided that E33 shouldn't win Best Music because it also won Best Art Direction, that's unfair to the composers and musicians who worked on E33.
-
I'm not saying E33 didn't deserve to win anything, but I don't believe it deserved to dominate like that. No single game should be allowed to do this, ever. I mean, of the 6 nominees for Best Performance, 3 of them (50%) were from E33. That shouldn't be allowed, IMO. Pick the single best performance from one game, then you can have more variety to pick from. Also, the winner of Best Indie Game should automatically be disqualified from also winning Best Indie Debut game. In my opinion: KCD2 snubbed for Best RPG, Silksong snubbed for best Action Adventure, and Half-Life 3 snubbed for Most Anticipated Game (is it disqualified -- no professionals allowed?).I don't see the point of limiting the nominees to just one-per-game, for best performance. There's still only one winner, and if that game legitimately had that many fantastic performances, more power to 'em. I'll second the idea of keeping Best Indie and Best Debut Indie separate. I'll go further and say E33 just isn't an Indie game, it's pretty solidly AA.
-
I'm not saying E33 didn't deserve to win anything, but I don't believe it deserved to dominate like that. No single game should be allowed to do this, ever. I mean, of the 6 nominees for Best Performance, 3 of them (50%) were from E33. That shouldn't be allowed, IMO. Pick the single best performance from one game, then you can have more variety to pick from. Also, the winner of Best Indie Game should automatically be disqualified from also winning Best Indie Debut game. In my opinion: KCD2 snubbed for Best RPG, Silksong snubbed for best Action Adventure, and Half-Life 3 snubbed for Most Anticipated Game (is it disqualified -- no professionals allowed?).
-
There's stupid people on both sides of the political spectrum.
-
Which is weird, since that game wasn't even marketed. I literally hadn't even heard of it till it started winning shit left and right
-
Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 I love E33 but the RPG mechanics are pretty barebones.
-
The parry mechanic completely ruined the combat for me, I still can't motivate myself to finish the game because of it.Most of the attacks are easy to parry, but about 1/4 of them are complete bullshit with unreadable animations and broken timing. I finished the game but didn't bother beating Simon. Apparently being level 95 with 20k health isn't enough. Completely unbalanced game.
-
I'm not saying E33 didn't deserve to win anything, but I don't believe it deserved to dominate like that. No single game should be allowed to do this, ever. I mean, of the 6 nominees for Best Performance, 3 of them (50%) were from E33. That shouldn't be allowed, IMO. Pick the single best performance from one game, then you can have more variety to pick from. Also, the winner of Best Indie Game should automatically be disqualified from also winning Best Indie Debut game. In my opinion: KCD2 snubbed for Best RPG, Silksong snubbed for best Action Adventure, and Half-Life 3 snubbed for Most Anticipated Game (is it disqualified -- no professionals allowed?).This is why some award shows have an award for being so outstanding you're in danger of ruining the show by taking all the awards. They give the award to them at the beginning and remove them from all categories, basically letting everyone play for second place. I think more than specifically any game being better at X than E33, I think a lot of people are mostly just upset there were so many great games that just didn't win anything because E33 was there.
